Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

The New York metro area has more than 20 million people, while Nashville, Tenn., has less than 2 million. In Los Angeles, 70 percent of the population is nonwhite, while in Boston that figure is 29 percent. Nearly a quarter of Toronto residents take public transportation, while only 1 percent of those who live in Dallas, Indianapolis and Raleigh, N.C., commute the same way. Boston has 15 top universities within 50 miles; Columbus, Ohio, only one. Certainly, while the contenders for Amazon’s second headquarters are clustered largely on the East Coast and in major metropolitan areas, there are notable differences among the 20 in demographics and statistics related to subjects Amazon has said are important.

How the 20 contenders rank

Atlanta

Austin, Texas

Boston

Chicago

Columbus, Ohio

Dallas

Denver

Indianapolis

Los Angeles

Miami

Montgomery County, Md.

Nashville, Tenn.

New York

Newark, N.J.

Northern Virginia

Philadelphia

Pittsburgh

Raleigh, N.C.

Toronto

Washington, D.C.

Chicago-area bid
Other contender bid

Population

In 2016, for metro area

New York
20.2M

Newark, N.J.
20.2M

Montgomery County, Md.
1.04M

Northern Virginia
6.13M

Washington, D.C.
6.13M

Boston
4.79M

Chicago
9.51M

Philadelphia
6.07M

Pittsburgh
2.34M

Los Angeles
13.3M

Denver
2.85M

Miami
6.07M

Atlanta
5.79M

Austin, Texas
2.06M

Columbus, Ohio
2.04M

Raleigh, N.C.
1.3M

Nashville, Tenn.
1.87M

Dallas
7.23M

Indianapolis
2M

Toronto
5.93M

1.04M

Median

20.2M

Why it’s important: The first preference outlined in Amazon’s request for proposals is that it prefers to be in a metropolitan area with at least 1 million people.

Median age

In 2016, for metro area

New York
38.2

Newark, N.J.
38.2

Montgomery County, Md.
39.0

Northern Virginia
36.9

Washington, D.C.
36.9

Boston
38.8

Chicago
37.2

Philadelphia
38.6

Pittsburgh
43.1

Los Angeles
36.6

Denver
36.5

Miami
40.9

Atlanta
36.2

Austin, Texas
34.4

Columbus, Ohio
35.8

Raleigh, N.C.
36.4

Nashville, Tenn.
36.3

Dallas
34.8

Indianapolis
36.3

Toronto
39.4

34.4

Median

43.1

Why it’s important: The second headquarters could employ as many as 50,000 people and Amazon has said its goal is to pick a location that allows it to retain a strong pool of workers.

Young population

Percentage younger than 30 years old, 2016, for metro area

New York
38.0%

Newark, N.J.
38.0%

Montgomery County, Md.
38.0%

Northern Virginia
40.0%

Washington, D.C.
40.0%

Boston
39.0%

Chicago
40.0%

Philadelphia
39.0%

Pittsburgh
34.0%

Los Angeles
40.0%

Denver
40.0%

Miami
35.0%

Atlanta
41.0%

Austin, Texas
42.0%

Columbus, Ohio
41.0%

Raleigh, N.C.
40.0%

Nashville, Tenn.
41.0%

Dallas
43.0%

Indianapolis
41.0%

Toronto
36.9%

34.0%

Median

43.0%

Why it’s important: The number of young people in an area could speak to the long-term ability of a city to respond to Amazon’s demand for workers.

Racial diversity

Percentage of population that is nonwhite, 2016

New York
53.0%

Newark, N.J.
53.0%

Montgomery County, Md.
56.0%

Northern Virginia
54.0%

Washington, D.C.
54.0%

Boston
29.0%

Chicago
47.0%

Philadelphia
38.0%

Pittsburgh
14.0%

Los Angeles
70.0%

Denver
35.0%

Miami
69.0%

Atlanta
52.0%

Austin, Texas
47.0%

Columbus, Ohio
26.0%

Raleigh, N.C.
38.0%

Nashville, Tenn.
27.0%

Dallas
53.0%

Indianapolis
27.0%

Toronto
51.4%

0.0%

Median

70.0%

Why it’s important: Amazon is looking for a headquarters location that is a cultural fit and that includes, it said in its proposal, a diverse population.

Public transportation use

Percentage of workers over age 16, 2016

New York
31.0%

Newark, N.J.
31.0%

Montgomery County, Md.
16.0%

Northern Virginia
13.0%

Washington, D.C.
13.0%

Boston
13.0%

Chicago
12.0%

Philadelphia
9.0%

Pittsburgh
6.0%

Los Angeles
5.0%

Denver
4.0%

Miami
4.0%

Atlanta
3.0%

Austin, Texas
2.0%

Columbus, Ohio
2.0%

Raleigh, N.C.
1.0%

Nashville, Tenn.
1.0%

Dallas
1.0%

Indianapolis
1.0%

Toronto
24.3%

0.0%

Median

31.0%

Why it’s important: Access to public transportation at its second headquarters site is a key requirement. The company’s commitment to sustainability was also expressed in its RFP.

College educated

Percentage of those over age 25 with a bachelor’s degree or higher

New York
39.0%

Newark, N.J.
39.0%

Montgomery County, Md.
59.2%

Northern Virginia
50.2%

Washington, D.C.
50.2%

Boston
46.9%

Chicago
37.2%

Philadelphia
36.7%

Pittsburgh
34.7%

Los Angeles
33.5%

Denver
42.5%

Miami
30.5%

Atlanta
37.7%

Austin, Texas
42.8%

Columbus, Ohio
36.0%

Raleigh, N.C.
47.2%

Nashville, Tenn.
34.2%

Dallas
33.9%

Indianapolis
33.8%

Toronto
40.9%

0.0%

Median

59.2%

Why it’s important: The scale of the employment requirements would mean the company is looking for an area with a high level of education: “A highly educated labor pool is critical,” Amazon’s RFP said.

Median income

Per household, 2016, for metro area

New York
$71,897.00

Newark, N.J.
$71,897.00

Montgomery County, Md.
$99,763.00

Northern Virginia
$95,843.00

Washington, D.C.
$95,843.00

Boston
$82,380.00

Chicago
$66,020.00

Philadelphia
$65,996.00

Pittsburgh
$56,063.00

Los Angeles
$65,950.00

Denver
$71,926.00

Miami
$51,362.00

Atlanta
$62,613.00

Austin, Texas
$71,000.00

Columbus, Ohio
$60,294.00

Raleigh, N.C.
$71,685.00

Nashville, Tenn.
$60,030.00

Dallas
$63,812.00

Indianapolis
$56,750.00

Toronto
$78,373.00

$51,362.00

Median

$99,763.00

Why it’s important: Amazon has pointed out that the average compensation at the second headquarters would exceed $100,000. An area’s median income speaks to how those potential Amazon jobs would compare, and gives a sense of the area’s labor pool and economic health.

People living in poverty

Percentage of people with incomes below the poverty line in 2016

New York
13.5%

Newark, N.J.
13.5%

Montgomery County, Md.
6.7%

Northern Virginia
8.4%

Washington, D.C.
8.4%

Boston
9.6%

Chicago
12.4%

Philadelphia
12.9%

Pittsburgh
10.9%

Los Angeles
15.0%

Denver
9.4%

Miami
15.4%

Atlanta
13.1%

Austin, Texas
10.9%

Columbus, Ohio
14.2%

Raleigh, N.C.
10.0%

Nashville, Tenn.
11.6%

Dallas
12.7%

Indianapolis
13.3%

Toronto
12.8%

0.0%

Median

15.4%

Why it’s important: In Amazon’s RFP, directly after the size of the area’s population is the company’s preference for a stable business environment. The poverty level of an area is one reflection of that.

Civilian labor force

Total available workers older than 16, November 2017

New York
10M

Newark, N.J.
10M

Montgomery County, Md.
3.38M

Northern Virginia
3.38M

Washington, D.C.
3.38M

Boston
2.68M

Chicago
4.88M

Philadelphia
3.09M

Pittsburgh
1.2M

Los Angeles
6.76M

Denver
1.61M

Miami
3.14M

Atlanta
3.05M

Austin, Texas
1.15M

Columbus, Ohio
45,041

Raleigh, N.C.
705K

Nashville, Tenn.
1.01M

Dallas
3.81M

Indianapolis
1.03M

Toronto
3.54M

45,041

Median

10M

Why it’s important: If a second headquarters is to employ 50,000 workers, a large pool of eligible workers is a must.

Unemployment rate

November 2017

New York
4.3%

Newark, N.J.
4.3%

Montgomery County, Md.
3.6%

Northern Virginia
3.6%

Washington, D.C.
3.6%

Boston
3.0%

Chicago
4.7%

Philadelphia
4.4%

Pittsburgh
4.3%

Los Angeles
3.8%

Denver
2.8%

Miami
4.1%

Atlanta
4.2%

Austin, Texas
2.7%

Columbus, Ohio
5.1%

Raleigh, N.C.
3.9%

Nashville, Tenn.
2.6%

Dallas
3.2%

Indianapolis
3.1%

Toronto
5.5%

0.0%

Median

5.5%

Why it’s important: The unemployment rate is also a reflection of an area’s economic health and can signal whether an area is business-friendly.

Workers in professional services sector

This major industry sector includes scientific and technical fields, for 2016

New York
1.52M

Newark, N.J.
1.52M

Montgomery County, Md.
738K

Northern Virginia
738K

Washington, D.C.
738K

Boston
469K

Chicago
819K

Philadelphia
460K

Pittsburgh
183K

Los Angeles
901K

Denver
257K

Miami
424K

Atlanta
491K

Austin, Texas
169K

Columbus, Ohio
180K

Raleigh, N.C.
112K

Nashville, Tenn.
156K

Dallas
581K

Indianapolis
168K

Toronto
358K

112K

Median

1.52M

Why it’s important: The jobs likely to be filled at the second headquarters are “excutive/management, engineering with a preference for software development engineers, legal, accounting and administrative,” Amazon said.

Available housing units

Houses, apartments or rooms intended to be living quarters, 2016.

New York
7.92M

Newark, N.J.
7.92M

Montgomery County, Md.
391K

Northern Virginia
2.34M

Washington, D.C.
2.34M

Boston
1.93M

Chicago
3.82M

Philadelphia
2.46M

Pittsburgh
1.11M

Los Angeles
4.61M

Denver
1.15M

Miami
2.53M

Atlanta
2.27M

Austin, Texas
806K

Columbus, Ohio
851K

Raleigh, N.C.
520K

Nashville, Tenn.
761K

Dallas
2.74M

Indianapolis
850K

Toronto
0

0

Median

7.92M

Why it’s important: Amazon’s RFP said it values high quality of life and asked bid cities to detail housing near potential sites.

Nearby universities

Total on U.S. News Best Colleges 2018 rankings, within 50 miles

New York
17

Newark, N.J.
17

Montgomery County, Md.
10

Northern Virginia
10

Washington, D.C.
10

Boston
15

Chicago
9

Philadelphia
11

Pittsburgh
5

Los Angeles
11

Denver
5

Miami
5

Atlanta
6

Austin, Texas
2

Columbus, Ohio
1

Raleigh, N.C.
3

Nashville, Tenn.
5

Dallas
7

Indianapolis
3

Toronto
4

1

Median

17

Why it’s important: In its requirements for a labor pool, Amazon’s request said, “A highly educated labor pool is critical and a strong university system is required.”

Airport size

Total passengers in 2016 at area’s largest airport

New York
59.1M

Newark, N.J.
40.6M

Montgomery County, Md.
23.6M

Northern Virginia
23.6M

Washington, D.C.
23.6M

Boston
36.4M

Chicago
78M

Philadelphia
30.2M

Pittsburgh
8.31M

Los Angeles
80.9M

Denver
58.3M

Miami
44.6M

Atlanta
104M

Austin, Texas
12.4M

Columbus, Ohio
7.32M

Raleigh, N.C.
11M

Nashville, Tenn.
13M

Dallas
65.7M

Indianapolis
8.51M

Toronto
44.3M

7.32M

Median

104M

Why it’s important: Amazon prefers the second headquarters to be within 45 minutes of an international airport. The RFP said an important consideration is access to daily flights to Seattle, New York, San Francisco and Washington, D.C.

Cost of living

Amount that would have to be earned to be equivalent to $100,000 in Seattle, 2018

New York
$159,830.00

Newark, N.J.
$84,936.00

Montgomery County, Md.
$104,950.00

Northern Virginia
$104,950.00

Washington, D.C.
$104,950.00

Boston
$104,253.00

Chicago
$84,158.00

Philadelphia
$85,926.00

Pittsburgh
$66,054.00

Los Angeles
$99,081.00

Denver
$76,874.00

Miami
$77,369.00

Atlanta
$69,307.00

Austin, Texas
$66,690.00

Columbus, Ohio
$63,154.00

Raleigh, N.C.
$65,488.00

Nashville, Tenn.
$66,124.00

Dallas
$69,661.00

Indianapolis
$63,932.00

Toronto
$79,826.39

$63,154.00

Median

$159,830.00

Why it’s important: Amazon asked bid proposals to include data on cost of living.

Homicide rate

Number of homicides per 100,000 people, 2014, for metro area

New York
3.1

Newark, N.J.
3.1

Montgomery County, Md.
5.46

Northern Virginia
5.46

Washington, D.C.
5.46

Boston
8.1

Chicago
15.09

Philadelphia
7.45

Pittsburgh
3.48

Los Angeles
8.26

Denver
4.66

Miami
14.99

Atlanta
20.47

Austin, Texas
3.54

Columbus, Ohio
9.99

Raleigh, N.C.
6.38

Nashville, Tenn.
9.17

Dallas
9.12

Indianapolis
35.39

Toronto
2.1

2.1

Median

35.39

Why it’s important: In its request for proposals, Amazon asked bid cities to include crime data.

Number of parks

Number of parks per 10,000 people, 2015, for city area

New York
2.6

Newark, N.J.
3.5

Montgomery County, Md.
6.2

Northern Virginia
6.2

Washington, D.C.
6.2

Boston
6.9

Chicago
2.8

Philadelphia
2.5

Pittsburgh
7

Los Angeles
1.8

Denver
4.3

Miami
2.8

Atlanta
8.9

Austin, Texas
3.5

Columbus, Ohio
5.1

Raleigh, N.C.
4.9

Nashville, Tenn.
4.4

Dallas
3

Indianapolis
2.5

Toronto
5.2

1.8

Median

8.9

Why it’s important: “We want to invest in a community where our employees will enjoy living, recreational opportunities, educational opportunities and an overall high quality of life,” Amazon’s RFP said.

Note: Data used is for the metropolitan regions with the exception of Montgomery County, Md. Data for the New York-Newark, N.J., metropolitan area was used to represent both of those contenders except for categories where city data was more accurate and different between the two bids. Data for the Washington, D.C., metropolitan area was used for the northern Virginia and Washington bids. Poverty rate for Toronto is the percentage under the low income line before taxes.

Sources: Censusreporter.com, Statistics Canada, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Department of Transportation, City of Toronto, United Nations Sustainability Development Solutions Network, U.S. Cities SDG Index, U.S. News and World Report, Airports Council International Annual World Airport Traffic Report 2017, The Trust for Public Land, INRIX Global Traffic Scorecard, www.nerdwallet.com, www.nubeo.com

@ChiTribGraphics

//graphics.chicagotribune.com/amazon-hq2-finalists/js/app.min.js
(function(document) {
var CSS = [
“//graphics.chicagotribune.com/amazon-hq2-finalists/css/styles.css”
];
CSS.forEach(function(url) {
var link = document.createElement(‘link’);
link.setAttribute(‘rel’, ‘stylesheet’);
link.setAttribute(‘href’, url);
document.head.appendChild(link);
});
})(document);