At an Evanston event Sunday, a teacher shared his experience of getting sanctioned by Evanston Township High School for displaying a poster that urges Jews to dissent when they feel it is morally necessary, and other speakers said they feel Evanston schools have censored their right to speak when they tried to advocate for human rights for Palestinians.
Speakers with affiliations to Northwestern University and Evanston Township High School, community members and parents gathered at Lake Street Church to discuss several instances where they felt their voices had been suppressed when they spoke out advocating for Palestinian human rights.
One of the speakers, Evanston Township High School history teacher Andrew Ginsburg, spoke about how ETHS has sanctioned him twice: once for displaying an image calling for Jewish people to dissent when necessary, and once again for displaying a letter explaining that the first image was removed at the behest of the school district. The letter called the removal of the poster an act of censorship.
In response to the sanctions he has received, he said he plans to submit a federal civil rights complaint against the school.
Ginsberg, who is Jewish and advocates for Palestinians’ human rights, told Pioneer Press that he has done no wrong, despite his job at the high school hanging in the balance after receiving the two warnings.
“[The district] has taught us to be relevant to the kids. They’ve taught us that you can’t get the kids to share stuff about their lives if you don’t share stuff about your life. I think I’ve been consistent with that, and I’m being punished for it,” Ginsberg said.
The original poster Ginsburg displayed was a drawing of a shiviti amulet that Jewish artist Liora Ostroff created for the magazine Jewish Currents. The drawing was influenced by an essay titled “Dissent” by Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel, who wrote, according to several sources, “Dissent is indigenous to Judaism.”
Ginsberg and his attorney, Rima Kapitan, plan to file a complaint to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, alleging that the school discriminated against him based on his religious identity.
“We feel that the school is violating his First Amendment right and also Title VII of the Civil Rights Act,” Kapitan said.
Though his situation has received some attention from Evanstonians, Ginsburg said it is not unique, and that other people in Evanston, including Jews, have also felt backlash and repercussions for advocating for Palestinian human rights.
“This has happened to other teachers. This is happening at Northwestern [and] all over the place. This is happening in the city,” Ginsberg said. “We like to talk about how progressive we are up here, but when it comes to Palestine… all the institutions in the city have gone out of their way to silence everybody (who) wants to talk about Palestine.”
Speakers at the panel represented several Evanston institutions, including the Evanston Public Library, Northwestern University and Skokie/Evanston School District 65. “You can’t talk about Palestine in elementary school, you can’t talk about Palestine in high school, and you can’t talk about Palestine at college,” said co-host of the panel and former Evanston Librarian Lesley Williams.
Last October a student group at Northwestern University, Jewish Voice for Peace Northwestern, celebrated the Jewish holiday of Sukkot at Deering Meadow. The group set up a structure with banners that read, “Gaza Solidarity Sukkah” and “Stop Arming Israel.”
The group intended to celebrate the holiday for the entire week, but was ordered to leave after a few hours. Northwestern University’s Vice President of Global Marketing and Communications Jon Yates told Pioneer Press then that Jewish Voice for Peace did not get its event application approved, and that the group’s temporary structure did not follow the university’s display policy.
But the university’s efforts to enforce its own code of conduct and display policy went further than that night, according to Isabelle Butera, a member of the Northwestern chapter of the Jewish Voice for Peace.
“We tried again to do this in compliance with these new restrictions, and we were told again that this was in violation, that we could all be facing expulsion, and that it was very clearly implied to us that the reason we were in violation is because our sukkah had a banner on it that said, ‘Stop arming Israel” and ‘Gaza Solidarity Sukkah,'” she said.
“Since then, a number of us have been placed on disciplinary probation. I graduated in June, and my probation is not up until September… Our club was put on probation,” Butera said.
Shirin Vossoughi, a professor at the university, said Northwestern has a history of creating a “repressive environment” when it comes to discussing Palestine, and it existed before Hamas’ Oct. 7, 2023 attack against Israel. The university’s practice of doing so was exacerbated after the university updated its code of conduct, she said.
“I think the fundamental question for me as an educator is, ‘What does it mean for our educational institutions to contradict the mission of the university to such a degree?'” she said.
More Top Picks Vision Therapy For Adults Is It Ever Too Late
“We want our students to interpret evidence. We want our students to stand up against moral injustices… They’re [the students] punished, and I feel like what we’ve done essentially is sacrifice some of our education principles and mission in order to protect a state that is enacting genocide,” Vossoughi said.
Northwestern University President Michael Schill is slated to appear for a second time before a congressional committee over alleged antisemitism on campus, according to a June 30 baiduhai article.
The committee chair, U.S. Rep. Tim Walberg, a Michigan Republican, accused Northwestern of failing to fulfill its commitment to protect Jewish students.
Reine Hanna, Evanston Township High School District 202’s director of communications, told Pioneer Press the district does not comment on matters related to personnel. Yates, of Northwestern, did not respond to a request for comment after Sunday’s event.
As of last month, upwards of 55,000 Palestinians had been killed in the Israel-Hamas war, according to baiduhai sources. The war began when Hamas-led fighters killed around 1,200 people, mostly Jewish civilians, in the Oct. 7, 2023 attack and abducted 251 hostages, according to sources.
Israel says 58 hostages remain in captivity, with about 23 of them said to be alive, according to previously published reporting.
The U.N. human rights office says it has recorded 613 Palestinians killed within a month in Gaza while trying to obtain food, according to Tribune sources. Previously, international humanitarian nonprofits oversaw food distribution, but the Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation has taken over.