Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
Fossil of a landbird

A 51.5 million year old landbird fossil (Smithsonian Museum of Natural History)

The Field Museum has more than a half-million fossils in its collection comprising all manner of plants and animals. It includes fossils from 430 million-year-old trilobites from Chicagoland’s Silurian reef to 195 million-year-old dinosaurs from Antarctica to 7,000-year-old humans from Iran, Iraq and Turkey.

Those relics alone offer clues as to how animals and plants once lived, but an ongoing effort by researchers seeks more: a digital database of fossils that aims to help understand evolution. The idea was hatched at the Field Museum and combines the very old — fossils, some as old as 500 million years — and the very new, open-access science on the Web.

In 2008 at the Field Musuem, evolutionary biologist Jim Parham was studying biodiversity on a project with the goal to fill out the tree of life, a diagram of all living things over time and how they relate to each other. “I was realizing that there was a major disconnect between the people who looked at the timing of the tree of life using fossils, and those that looked at it using DNA,” Parham said. Scientists who use DNA to study evolution were not able to easily access information from fossils that could help them, and when they did, Parham said, they were doing it incorrectly.

How to address the disconnect? Bring paleontologists, molecular biologists, computer programmers and others together in a completely new way. Here is how it happened.

Tree of Life diagram

An illustration courtesy Tree of Life web project

The tree of life

Imagine every type of plant and animal that ever lived, organized as a big tree. When new species emerge, new branches are formed. When a species goes extinct, a branch ends. The database of fossils helps determine when the splits and ends of the branches happen.

“What we are trying to do is reconstruct the timing of evolutionary events,” said Daniel Ksepka, who helped lead the effort and edits the database. “What we do is use fossils to calibrate the (evolutionary) clock,” he said. Ksepka is a curator at the Bruce Museum in Greenwich, Ct., and was a research associate at the Field Museum.

Kenneth Angielczyk, associate curator of paleomammalogy at the Field, said molecular clock dating has become a key technique in evolutionary biology. “The method considers the rate at which DNA sequences change over time. Once that rate is known it is possible to estimate when two species last shared a common ancestor by comparing the degree to which their DNA sequences have diverged,” he said.

Angielczyk said the dates help scientists estimate important events in the history of life and to study the rates at which evolutionary changes occur for different forms of life in different circumstances. “Scientists use fossils to make these calibrations,” he said.

The lessons can go deeper, understanding evolution to learn about what might happen in the future. “The time that animals and plants split is widely variable,” said Adam Smith, who until last year was a postdoctoral fellow at the Field and now is curator of the Bob Campbell Geology Museum at Clemson University in South Carolina. “Correlating diversity and extinction with paleontological events, we can learn about how response might be now.”


.g-artboard {
margin:0 auto;
}

/* Custom CSS block 1 */
/*
Normal, everyday CSS can go here. To make the mobile toggling work, adjust the ID names below using this formula:

#g-{file name}-{artboard name}
*/

#g-database-mobile{display:none;}

@media all and (max-width:700px){
#g-database-mobile{display:block}
#g-database-desktop{display:none}
}

#g-database-desktop{
position:relative;
overflow:hidden;
width:400px;
}
.g-aiAbs{
position:absolute;
}
.g-aiImg{
display:block;
width:100% !important;
}
#g-database-desktop p{
font-family:nyt-franklin,arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:13px;
line-height:18px;
margin:0;
}
#g-database-desktop .g-aiPstyle0 {
font-family:arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:50px;
line-height:113px;
font-weight:bold;
text-align:center;
letter-spacing:-0.03333333333333em;
color:#7493c1;
}
#g-database-desktop .g-aiPstyle1 {
font-family:arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:14px;
line-height:25px;
font-weight:bold;
text-align:center;
color:#000000;
}
#g-database-desktop .g-aiPstyle2 {
font-family:arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:14px;
line-height:16px;
font-weight:bold;
text-align:center;
color:#000000;
}

36

32

23

17

15

Mammals

Birds

Fish

Primitive

animals

Reptiles

Plants: 5

Amphibians: 5

Other: 2

#g-database-mobile{
position:relative;
overflow:hidden;
width:296px;
}
.g-aiAbs{
position:absolute;
}
.g-aiImg{
display:block;
width:100% !important;
}
#g-database-mobile p{
font-family:nyt-franklin,arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:13px;
line-height:18px;
margin:0;
}
#g-database-mobile .g-aiPstyle0 {
font-family:arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:63px;
line-height:113px;
font-weight:bold;
text-align:center;
letter-spacing:-0.03333333333333em;
color:#7493c1;
}
#g-database-mobile .g-aiPstyle1 {
font-family:arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:14px;
line-height:25px;
font-weight:bold;
text-align:center;
color:#000000;
}
#g-database-mobile .g-aiPstyle2 {
font-family:arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:14px;
line-height:16px;
font-weight:bold;
text-align:center;
color:#000000;
}

36

Mammals

32

Birds

23

Fish

17

Primitive

animals

15

Reptiles

Amphibians: 5

Plants: 5

Other: 2

Telling fossil time

Using a fossil to determine a creature’s place in the tree of life, known as calibration, often was inconsistent and sometimes incorrect. There were no common standards or a central place to log the information.

“As it stood, molecular biologists were using fossil data but did not have the understanding to use it properly,” said Parham, now a paleontology and conservation biologist at California State University at Fullerton. “Consequently, they often got it wrong and used the wrong fossils or assigned the wrong dates.”

The database, part of the electronic journal “Palaeontologia Electronica”, puts all of that information in one place in a searchable format, with all fossils calibrated to the same standards.

The final product, which launched last year, is a tool for scientists that also happens to be available to all on the Internet. The database currently has 144 entries.


.g-artboard {
margin:0 auto;
}

/* Custom CSS block 1 */
/*
Normal, everyday CSS can go here. To make the mobile toggling work, adjust the ID names below using this formula:

#g-{file name}-{artboard name}
*/

#g-example-mobile{display:none;}

@media all and (max-width:700px){
#g-example-mobile{display:block}
#g-example-desktop{display:none}
}

#g-example-desktop{
position:relative;
overflow:hidden;
width:400px;
}
.g-aiAbs{
position:absolute;
}
.g-aiImg{
display:block;
width:100% !important;
}
#g-example-desktop p{
font-family:nyt-franklin,arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:13px;
line-height:18px;
margin:0;
}
#g-example-desktop .g-aiPstyle0 {
font-family:georgia,’times new roman’,times,serif;
font-size:14px;
line-height:16px;
color:#000000;
}

In 1991 Peter Crane, a Yale

paleontologist, discovered

fossils of flowered plants

outside Richmond, Va.

One of those fossils, a microscopic piece of a 107.7 million-year old laurales, stored at the Field Museum, turned out to be significant: It represents a key moment in the evolution in the group of plants that include avocado, cinnamon and bay laurels.

For that reason — because it represents a branching out of the evolutionary tree — the tiny sample is included in the fossil calibration database.

When a fossil is part of the database, here is what it includes:

Its lineage

Its age

Identifying details about the specific fossil

Its significance in terms of evolution

And a diagram of where it fits on the tree of life, relative to its closest relatives.

#g-example-mobile{
position:relative;
overflow:hidden;
width:296px;
}
.g-aiAbs{
position:absolute;
}
.g-aiImg{
display:block;
width:100% !important;
}
#g-example-mobile p{
font-family:nyt-franklin,arial,helvetica,sans-serif;
font-size:13px;
line-height:18px;
margin:0;
}
#g-example-mobile .g-aiPstyle0 {
font-family:georgia,’times new roman’,times,serif;
font-size:14px;
line-height:16px;
color:#000000;
}

In 1991 Peter Crane, a Yale

paleontologist, discovered

fossils of flowered plants

outside Richmond, Va.

One of those fossils, a microscopic piece of a 107.7 million-year old laurales, stored at the Field Museum, turned out to be significant: It represents a key moment in the evolution in the group of plants that include avocado, cinnamon and bay laurels.

For that reason — because it represents a branching out of the evolutionary tree — the tiny sample is included in the fossil calibration database.

When a fossil is part of the database, here is what it includes:

Its lineage

Its age

Identifying details about the specific fossil

Its significance in terms of evolution

And a diagram of where it fits on the tree of life, relative to its closest relatives.

Building the database

Each fossil entry into the database must first pass a rigorous process, Ksepka said, a process that nails down how old it is, where it was found and how it fits on the evolutionary tree. Publishing the calibration online also gives paleontologists a place where their work is published and can be cited.

How a fossil is verified

“Any fossil that is used as a calibration point must have a well-constrained age and position of the tree of life,” Angielczyk said.

  • Specimen: Each fossil is first based on an individual museum specimen or set of specimens; that makes sure the fossil in question is something that can be found.
  • Physical characteristics: Demonstrate that anatomical characteristics support the placement of the fossil in the evolutionary tree.
  • DNA vs. archeology: Reconcile any differences between evolutionary trees based on anatomical data and DNA.
  • Location: Identify the physical location from which the fossil was collected and tie it to a specific level in a rock formation.
  • Age: Translate that geological placement into a numerical age.
Scientists working on database project

The participants in the initial fossil calibration meeting at University of Bristol, west of London, in 2009. (Palaeo Electronica photo)

The scientists

As the idea to create a fossil database grew, it led to grants and gatherings of experts from the worlds of paleontology, molecular biology and computer programming. The support of the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center in North Carolina, now the Triangle Center for Evolutionary Medicine and other organizations was key to the effort. Over the course of the meetings from 2009 to 2014 there were nearly 40 people who attended, including 19 paleontologists, 13 molecular biologists, five computer scientists and one editor.

The mix paid off. “All of the different perspectives were extremely rewarding,” Ksepka said.

The next steps? Keep adding fossils to the database and fill in more branches of the tree. “We are hoping to grow the database,” Parham said. “Whereas we have good coverage of the basic branches of the tree of life, we need to fill it more.”

How does the tree get filled out? Parham said mainly through word of mouth, social media and speaking at conferences. “The project is open-ended, and since there are lots of branches to the tree of life that have fossils, I think we can definitely expect to get hundreds more, if not thousands eventually.”

The team is consistently hearing of new fossils to be entered and new scientists interesting in contributing.

“And that’s the really exciting thing, to realize that there will always be a need to know what is the oldest physical record of a lineage and so the database will always serve a purpose and continue to grow,” Parham said.

How old are the fossils: Timeline of what is in the database

The timeline below shows the fossils that are part of the database through 2015, along with significant evolutionary markers for context.

2015

200,000 years ago

Humans

1 million years ago

Murrelets

1 million years ago

Murrelets

2 million years ago

Gulls

2 million years ago

Murres

4 million years ago

Atlantic puffins

5 million years ago

5 million years ago

Elephants

6 million years ago

Humans and chimps

6 million years ago

Guillemots

6 million years ago

Puffins

7 million years ago

Razorbill auks

10 million years ago

Mice and rats

11 million years ago

Great apes

11 million years ago

Apes

11 million years ago

Arctic sandpipers

12 million years ago

Anacondas

12 million years ago

Pythons

13 million years ago

Stickleback fish

15 million years ago

Murres and dovekies

15 million years ago

Kangaroos and wallabies

15 million years ago

Platypuses and echidnas

16 million years ago

Buffaloes and antelopes

18 million years ago

Rubber boas

23 million years ago

Stone-curlews

24 million years ago

Old world monkeys

24 million years ago

Cormorants

25 million years ago

28 million years ago

Pelicans

30 million years ago

Jacanas

30 million years ago

Button quails

32.02 million years ago

Pufferfish

33 million years ago

Whales

33 million years ago

Simians

33 million years ago

Lemurs and lorises

34 million years ago

Auks

35 million years ago

Old World sand boas

35 million years ago

Mexican burrowing pythons

37 million years ago

Carnivorous mammals

40 million years ago

Guinea pigs and allies

41 million years ago

Wading birds

44 million years ago

Swamp roots

45 million years ago

Bats

45 million years ago

Chichlid fish

46 million years ago

Shorebirds

46 million years ago

Hoopoes

47 million years ago

Sea cows and dugongs

47 million years ago

Marsupials

47 million years ago

Rabbits

47 million years ago

Advanced rodents

47 million years ago

Sloths and armadillos

49 million years ago

Cichilids and ricefish

50 million years ago

51 million years ago

Swifts

51 million years ago

Roller birds

51 million years ago

Frigatebirds

52 million years ago

Even-toed ungulates

52 million years ago

Hippos and whales

53 million years ago

Parrots

53 million years ago

Ibises

56 million years ago

Caecilians (limbless amphibians)

56 million years ago

Tropicbirds

56 million years ago

African mammal group

56 million years ago

Rabbits and rodents

56 million years ago

Primates

56 million years ago

Rodents

56 million years ago

Mousebirds

56 million years ago

Ratites and tinamous

58 million years ago

Boas

60 million years ago

Birds

60 million years ago

Penguins

61 million years ago

Hedgehogs, shrews and moles

61 million years ago

Primates, tree shrews and colugos

61 million years ago

Mammals with external testicles

61 million years ago

Placental mammals

64.6 million years ago

Primates, rodents and allies

65 million years ago

Time period of T. rex

66 million years ago

Advanced birds

66 million years ago

Waterfowl

69 million years ago

Stickleback fish and pufferfish

69 million years ago

Advanced ray-finned fish

72 million years ago

Pipe snake

85 million years ago

Cinnamon and allies

93 million years ago

Gars

93 million years ago

Advanced snakes

98 million years ago

Spine-finned fishes

98 million years ago

Snakes

100 million years ago

107 million years ago

Laurels and allies

112 million years ago

Magnolias

120 million years ago

Sturgeons, paddlefishes and bichirs

125 million years ago

Sandalwood and allies

126 million years ago

Advanced hinge-jawed fish

146 million years ago

Salamanders

150 million years ago

Herringlike fish

150 million years ago

Catfish, carp and herrings

151 million years ago

Hinge-jawed fish

155 million years ago

Turtles

157 million years ago

Marsupials

164 million years ago

Mammals

165 million years ago

Frogs

200 million years ago

225 million years ago

First dinosaurs

238 million years ago

Lizards and tuatara

238 million years ago

Lizards

247 million years ago

Crocodilians and birds

250 million years ago

Pangea forms

250 million years ago

Frogs and salamanders

250 million years ago

Amphibians

250 million years ago

Gars and bowfins

250 million years ago

Advancd ray-finned fish

255 million years ago

Advanced reptiles

255 million years ago

Reptiles

300 million years ago

318 million years ago

Animals with watertight eggs

333 million years ago

Sharks and rays

337 million years ago

Four-legged vertebrates

358 million years ago

Lampreys and hagfish

378 million years ago

Ray-finned fishes

400 million years ago

408 million years ago

Lungfish

408 million years ago

Lobe-finned fish

420 million years ago

Land plants evolve

420 million years ago

Jawed fish

420 million years ago

Bony fish

450 million years ago

Arthropods move onto land

457 million years ago

Vertebrates

476 million years ago

Worms, snails and allies

500 million years ago

Fish-like vertebrates

504 million years ago

Sea stars, acorn worms and allies

509 million years ago

Starfish and sea urchins

514 million years ago

Animals with a nerve cord

514 million years ago

Tunicates and vertebrates

514 million years ago

Arthropods

515 million years ago

Sea stars, acorn worms and allies

515 million years ago

Deuterostome animals

528.82 million years ago

Molting animals

528.82 million years ago

Insects, crustaceans and allies

529 million years ago

Jellyfish

532 million years ago

Mollusks

550 million years ago

Bilaterally symetrical animals

550 million years ago

Animals with true tissues

550 million years ago

Animals

550 million years ago

Protostome animals

550 million years ago

Worms, snails and allies

555 million years ago

Multi-cell marine organisms

Sources: Palaeontolgia Electronica Fossil Calibration Database, The Field Museum, “The Illustrated Timeline of the History of the World” by Roshen Dalal, University of California Museum of Paleontology, National Center for Science Education, Tribune reporting

Note: The timeline includes 135 entries included in the database as of the end of 2015. More entries have been added since and more added in the future. Check here for updates.

http://graphics.chicagotribune.com/fossil-database/js/vendor.min.jshttp://graphics.chicagotribune.com/fossil-database/js/app.min.js
(function(document) {
var CSS = [
“//s3.amazonaws.com/media.apps.chicagotribune.com/graphics-toolbox/skeleton.css”,
“//graphics.chicagotribune.com/fossil-database/css/styles.css”
];
CSS.forEach(function(url) {
var link = document.createElement(‘link’);
link.setAttribute(‘rel’, ‘stylesheet’);
link.setAttribute(‘href’, url);
document.head.appendChild(link);
});
})(document);